|
|
North East Cases Panel updated 09.08.04 We have continued to look at the issues which concern us and not unexpectedly have recommended the use of timber sash and case replacement windows where applicants apply to use uPVC. This is a very real problem in conservation areas which may cause people much unnecessary distress - especially when they have gone ahead without making a planning application and then have to face the financial consequences of reversal. Another recurring factor which appears to retard progress when we are set to consider proposals is the need for more information regarding the context of each application. Photographs are helpful. We have on several occasions had to request the submission of clearer copies of drawings. Happily this problem is now showing signs of improvement and must therefore be of benefit to those directly involved. One outstanding urban application to occupy our group is the proposed five storey extension to His Majesty's Theatre in Aberdeen. At the outset it must be stated that the panel lends support in principle to the application to build an extension to the present building. However the present Edwardian Baroque facade of the theatre is in a prominent location and has a key role to play in the character of the architecture of the city of Aberdeen. The NE panel believes that the proposed extension does not respond to its place and is lacking in design detail. Adjectives used to describe the new facade were 'banal' and 'unispiring'. Another weakness identified was the failure to address the needs of the street-scape. Awareness also of the loss of the distant view towards Archibald Simpson's neo-classical Royal Infirmary and Broadford's 'Bastille' was discussed, as this will be the outcome if the building rises two storeys above street level in order to achieve the required accommodation. Perhaps we cannot have everything - but we should certainly take everything into account. This proposal was not deemed to be 'cutting-edge architecture' and the panel feels very strongly that this truly is an important opportunity to provide Aberdeen and its citizens with a design which befits the importance of the site. Looking to other recent Scottish projects such as the new Edinburgh Dance Theatre and the Scottish Poetry Library as inspirational solutions to design problems we suggested that this project be opened up to International Competition. Dorothy Laing |
|
